Skip to content
Big Rob's
Hauling

Demolition & Removal · a straight comparison

Should I repair my old deck or tear it out in Central Florida?

A deck with a few soft boards is a repair. A deck with rotted joists, posts or a ledger pulling off the house is a tear-out. Across Central Florida the repair is priced by the board and the tear-out is one flat demo-and-haul number, usually a half trailer at $350 or a full at $700, with the wood gone the same visit.

5.0 · 119 Google reviews · Davenport & Polk County

Kubota skid steer with a breaker attachment breaking up a concrete patio in Polk County, FL
Should I repair my old deck or tear it out in Central Florida?: comparison
 Repair itTear it out and haul it
What you findA few soft or split boards, solid framing underneathRotted joists, wobbly posts, a ledger pulling away, or termite damage
Cost shapeBy the board, plus the labor to swap themOne flat demo-and-haul quote: half trailer $350, full $700
TimeAn afternoon per section, repeated as more boards goA morning to a day, then it's gone
What comes afterThe same deck, a little longerA new deck, pavers, or lawn on bare ground
PermitsAsk the building department if the repair reaches the framingAsk the building department; when the job needs one, Rob works with a general contractor
What happens to the woodOld boards go in your trash or a dump runLandfill. Treated lumber isn't donated

When repairing wins

Repair when the problem is on top. Walk the deck and push on the boards. If a handful flex or split but the joists under them are hard when you poke them with a screwdriver, swap the boards and tighten the railings. Same for a loose stair tread or a railing post. You keep the deck and spend a fraction of what a new one costs.

When tearing it out wins

Tear it out when the problem is underneath. Joists that crumble at the screwdriver, posts that move when you lean on the rail, a ledger board separating from the house, or termite trails in the framing mean the boards on top don't matter. Patching over rotted framing buys a season and hides the risk. Rob's crew takes it down in order: railings and stairs, then boards, then joists, then posts and footings. The wood is loaded as it comes off, so the yard is clear when the trailer leaves.

What comes after the tear-out

Decide what goes in the footprint before demo day. A new deck may want the old posts left in; say so and the crew leaves them. Pavers or lawn want everything out, footings included. The skid steer pulls posts set in concrete, and those footings ride in the trailer with the lumber. Ask your city or the Polk County building department about permits for the tear-out and for whatever's next. When a job needs one, Rob works with a general contractor.

Where the wood goes

Old deck lumber goes to the landfill. It's treated, so it isn't donated and it shouldn't be burned. Composite goes the same way. If a contractor rebuilt and left the old boards in a pile, that's a regular pickup priced by how much trailer it fills.

One worked example

How Big Rob's measures up

Against the criteria above, with the review evidence, verbatim.

Big Rob's does the tear-out side. One flat number covers the demo, the loading and the haul, quoted from photos and a rough size. Deck wood is bulky but light, so the price follows trailer volume more than weight, and the crew loads as they go so nothing waits in the yard. Footings add a little weight and go along in the trailer.

The reviews below cover a deck-wood pickup and a small job whose price held. That's the shape of the quote whether it's a landing or a wraparound.

Google

Rob is awesome! Came within 2 days to pick up excess wood from a deck repair and cleaned it all out quickly. Price was fair as well. Thanks Rob and team!

Kim Tricker · this year

Google

Very professional,reasonable fair price, fast, no job to big or small,patient, and came same day which I really appreciate..didnt have huge amount to haul but they still kept price exact same with no bait& switch. Overall 5*

Cheryl Scotland · this year

Questions

What people ask

How do I know if my deck can be repaired?

Poke the joists and posts with a screwdriver. Solid framing means the boards on top can be swapped. If the screwdriver sinks in, the framing is done and the deck should come out.

How much does it cost to remove a deck in Polk County?

It's one flat number from photos. Most decks land at a half trailer, $350, or a full, $700, with the demo and haul included. A very large or multi-level deck can take more than one load, and Rob says so before he starts.

Can you leave the posts for a new deck?

Yes. Tell Rob you're rebuilding on the same posts and the crew leaves them. If you're going to pavers or grass, they pull the posts and footings too.

Ready for it to be gone?

Call before noon and it's usually gone today. Or text a photo of the pile and Rob sends back a flat quote.

5.0 · 119 Google reviews · Davenport & Polk County

(863) 225-2147Get a Quote